Hosted Case Study--Grotech Capital
Grotech Capital Group is a private equity firm with a 22-year winning track record and approximately one billion dollars under management. Grotech is a recognized leader investing in information technology, health care and consumer companies located in the eastern United States.
* Venture Capital & Private Equity firm * 22 years in the business – on 6th fund * Current fund $410 million (appx $1b under management) * 25 Employees in 2 offices (MD & VA)
Life Before Going Hosted
Before Hosted 3COM I PBX Tenure with Hosted 2 months Number of Employees 25 Number of Seats 38 Number of Locations 2
|
|
 |
- Prior System – 3com I-PBX
- Maintenance / Management Costs – 61% lower up front capex costs and
26% savings in TCO over IP PBX alternative
- What it did well that hosted would have to emulate?
– maintained ability to carry forward legacy key system operating methods that were ingrained in firm
- intercom /call announce
- personal screening
- Key Shortcomings:
– Terrible voice quality (no QOS) – Frequent outages – No other productivity features (e.g. unified messaging) | The Buying Process
- How long did it take to decide?
– approximately 6 months; used consultant; no experience with hosted; drove to wrong PBX solution – restarted process
- Sales person presentation & positioning:
– night & day
- PBX sales – well honed model
- hosted – varied widely – mostly very weak. not even comparable without coaching
- Competition
– IP-PBX: Cisco, Avaya, Mitel – Hosted: Non Broadsoft, Broadsoft (3 Carriers) | Key Driving Factors
- For Change:
– Terrible voice quality (PBX bypass!)
- For Hosted:
– Very limited internal IT/telecom expertise – Very difficult to get reliable external support for small business | The Trade Offs
|
|
Hosted |
|
IP PBX |
| Up front costs |
|
$ 32 k |
|
$ 83 k |
| Up front savings |
|
61% |
|
|
| Monthly costs |
|
$3 k |
|
$3.6 k |
| 5 Year TCO |
|
$225 k |
|
$302 k |
| Savings |
|
26% |
|
|
| Features |
|
***** |
|
**** |
| Ease of Administration |
|
***** |
|
*** | Unexpected Results
- Most people really hate change
- Unified messaging is a huge time saver and will be out standing when Blackberries can play wav files
- SIM ring is also a real productivity enhancer
- Ability to integrate cell phone and office voice mail to one is a major break through
- Negative – pushing send is unnatural on a desk phone
| The Expected Results
- Voice quality is just fine
- At desk productivity greatly enhanced w/ Outlook integration, tool bar, etc.
- Office Manager seems much happier!
- Whining has dropped significantly
- Clearly will lower costs over time
- Once we get used to all these features – every thing else will feel like a rotary phone.
| Report Card
System Reliability A Sound Quality B+ Features A
 |